PDA

View Full Version : This over That



cbsmokin
02-04-2009, 07:41
I have a thread idea, maybe it has been done before, but why not do it again. Give me a list of your this over that.

For example maybe you say Bookers over Basil Haydens or something along that line.

I think this could be helpful to newer people (like myself) when considering different things to try. Include all price ranges.

To make it easy you can just type with a slash to make a list.

This / That

Let's hear it.

Vange
02-04-2009, 08:10
A few off the top of my head

Elmer T Lee vs ER10
RHF vs Blanton's
Pappy 15 vs Pappy 20
Bookers vs Bakers
WTRB vs WTKS

funknik
02-04-2009, 08:11
I love this idea, but it sounds like what I do every time I go to the liquor store. Most of the time I'm thinking in terms of what is a better value (i.e. less money) for a similar or superior bottle (in my own opinion, of course), but sometimes, what's a better pour in a similar price point (again, IMO). Here are some easy ones:

Elijah Craig 12 / Knob Creek

WL Weller Special Reserve / Maker's Mark

Wild Turkey Rye 101 / Russel's Reserve Rye

Ancient Ancient Age 10yr / Eagle Rare Single Barrel 10/90

George Dickel No.12 / Jack Daniel's

Wild Turkey Rare Breed / Blanton's

Baker's / Booker's

Van Winkle Lot 'B' / Pappy 20

funknik
02-04-2009, 08:13
A few off the top of my head

Elmer T Lee vs ER10
RHF vs Blanton's
Pappy 15 vs Pappy 20
Bookers vs Bakers
WTRB vs WTKS
That's funny, we went opposite on the Booker's and the Baker's.....what's your stand on Candlestick Makers?

fishnbowljoe
02-04-2009, 14:36
All bourbon / ice. :slappin: Joe

sotnsipper
02-04-2009, 14:42
All bourbon / ice. :slappin: Joe


Love your idea:lol:!!! Going on that idea here are a couple.

Ice over Coke

Neat over Ice

And another one.

Anything 100+ proof over and 80 proofer.

fishnbowljoe
02-04-2009, 14:59
I hope I get to meet you at the KBF Ty. Not everyone laughs at my jokes.:rolleyes: I appreciate it.:lol: Joe

Blitz
02-04-2009, 16:03
Weller Antique over Makers
Buffalo Trace over Elijah Craig 12
Knob Creek over Woodford Reserve
Pappy 15 over Pappy 20
Bookers over just about anything

Looking at my list, appearantly I'll take BT and Beam Small Batch against the field. Didn't realize.

OscarV
02-04-2009, 16:52
I love this idea, but it sounds like what I do every time I go to the liquor store. Most of the time I'm thinking in terms of what is a better value (i.e. less money) for a similar or superior bottle (in my own opinion, of course), but sometimes, what's a better pour in a similar price point (again, IMO). Here are some easy ones:

Elijah Craig 12 / Knob Creek

WL Weller Special Reserve / Maker's Mark

Wild Turkey Rye 101 / Russel's Reserve Rye

Ancient Ancient Age 10yr / Eagle Rare Single Barrel 10/90

George Dickel No.12 / Jack Daniel's

Wild Turkey Rare Breed / Blanton's

Baker's / Booker's

Van Winkle Lot 'B' / Pappy 20

Ah, you learn well young man, I agree with everyone.

funknik
02-04-2009, 17:01
Ah, you learn well young man, I agree with everyone.
Thank You, sir.....the support is appreciated.

callmeox
02-04-2009, 19:21
I hope I get to meet you at the KBF Ty. Not everyone laughs at my jokes.:rolleyes: I appreciate it.:lol: Joe

Stick around late enough at the Gazebo and you will get to see this in person. :slappin:


I'll counter with

Russel's Reserve Rye / WT 101 Rye

The WT rye gives me a freshly punched in the throat feeling every time I try it again.

ILLfarmboy
02-04-2009, 19:49
The WT rye gives me a freshly punched in the throat feeling every time I try it again.

What's the matter.....don't you like that freshly punched in the throat feeling?











wuss :grin:

Attila
02-04-2009, 19:55
fishnets over nylon hose

Lost Pollito
02-04-2009, 20:55
Stick around late enough at the Gazebo and you will get to see this in person. :slappin:


I'll counter with

Russel's Reserve Rye / WT 101 Rye

The WT rye gives me a freshly punched in the throat feeling every time I try it again.

What you doin to get punched in the throat? Maybe to much of that 101 makes you a lil wild?:lol:

Lost Pollito
02-04-2009, 20:56
fishnets over nylon hose
I'll take the fishnets.:rolleyes:

fishnbowljoe
02-04-2009, 21:36
I'll take anything I can get. Thanks Scott. Love you like a brother. Joe

cbsmokin
02-05-2009, 09:06
Anyone care to put all their over / unders in one long chain? In other words rank em how you would drink them all sitting in front of you? I bet it's harder than you think.

And to add to the off topic ...

Thong / Full Coverage
Real / Silicone or Saline
Porsche / Corvette

spun_cookie
02-05-2009, 09:37
Wemon/me
Me/Wemon

Could not resist :yum: :crazy:

sailor22
02-05-2009, 11:13
motorcycles/cars
Ducati/Honda
Bourbon/Scotch
neat/rocks
experience/youth
van winkle/Jim Beam
Wild Turkey/Jack Daniels
sweet/dry
comfortable/thin
rum/gin
armagnac/cognac

kickert
02-05-2009, 14:24
Buffalo Trace / Heaven Hill
Weller 12 / Lot B
EC12 / EC18
Rittenhouse Rye / WT Rye
Old Charter / AAA

EricABQ
02-05-2009, 14:28
EC 12 over 18
Pappy 15 over 20
Kentucky Spirit over Rare Breed

ggilbertva
02-05-2009, 14:55
Weller Antique / Weller SR
WT 8 yr 101 / WT 101 current
Blantons Gold /Blantons Original
AAA 10 year / ER 10/90
Pleasure / pain
Laughter / tears
Corvette / tricycle
Pat on the back / sharp poke in the eye

ILLfarmboy
02-05-2009, 21:32
Rare breed / 101
WTRR 101 / RR90
Weller Antique / Maker's Mark
Booker's / any other current Beam
WT Rye / WTRR 90
OGD BIB / Bulleit
Sazerac Rye / Beam Rye

smokinjoe
02-07-2009, 09:58
Baby Saz over RRR
OGD 114 over Booker's
Evan Williams over Jim Beam
EC18 over EC12
Pappy 15 over Pappy 20
Lot B over Pappy 20
Maker's over Woodford
ER 10yr SB over ER 101
VOB 100 proof over EW 100 proof
BHC OCPR 13 over BHC Weller Centennial
Dickel over Daniel's
Vya Sweet over Noilly Sweet


Infiniti over Lexus
Ford Pickup over Chevy Pickup
Bud over Miller
95 F over 35 F
Lo rider boy shorts "shorties" over thongs (No, not for me ;))
Centerlines over Cragar S/S
Omaha over Hold 'em
Gazebo Table over Sampler
Wood Bat over Aluminum Bat
Aerosmith over Rolling Stones
Robin Meade/Christi Paul :bowdown: (Push :yum:)
Ginger over Mary Ann
Jeannie over Ginger
Dodgers over Angels
White Sox over Cubs
Giants over A's
Mets/Yankees (2 wrongs don't make a right :D)

funknik
12-04-2009, 09:45
Let's see how far we've come in almost a year:

AAA 10yr > RHF > ETL > Blanton's
Buffalo Trace > ERSB10/90 > OC10
WTKS = RB > WT101 > RR90
Weller12 > OWA > WLW SR > MM > any current Old Fitz
WTRye101 = Sazerac > Ritt BIB > ri1 > RR Rye 90 > JB Rye
OGD114 > Baker's > Booker's > KC > OGD
4R Yellow > 4Rsmb
EWSB > EC12 = Mckenna BIB

(and, as an afterthought, if I'm out at a bar & really want a whiskey here's my preference (the selection sucks here!): Black Bush = WT101 > KC > OGD86 > MM)

I like this thread, so I thought I'd give it a bump so some of the newer members could chime in.