PDA

View Full Version : Is it me?



Sipper
04-14-2009, 17:07
Does anyone besides me think that Evan Williams and Jack Daniel's has a similiar taste? I know, EW's a Kentucky bourbon and JD's a charcoal-filtered Tennessee whskey, but nevertheless, I swear, to me EW tastes just like its Tennessee cousin. And don't think my taste buds are completely eroded. I can tell a big difference between Daniel's and Dickel. And, no, Dickel doesn't taste like EW to me in case you're wondering.

Stones
04-14-2009, 19:38
I don't like EW or JD so there could be some truth in it, for obvious reasons i've never done a side by side tasting of them.

p_elliott
04-15-2009, 07:35
absolutely not JD taste like charcoal EW is very good bourbon.

Josh
04-15-2009, 10:32
Does anyone besides me think that Evan Williams and Jack Daniel's has a similiar taste? I know, EW's a Kentucky bourbon and JD's a charcoal-filtered Tennessee whskey, but nevertheless, I swear, to me EW tastes just like its Tennessee cousin. And don't think my taste buds are completely eroded. I can tell a big difference between Daniel's and Dickel. And, no, Dickel doesn't taste like EW to me in case you're wondering.

There's something about EW & JD in Chuck's book. I believe that there was at one time a JD shortage. Other brands were created (by other companies) to capitalize on this. HH released EW (square bottle, black label, man's name) and the Ripys came out with Ezra Brooks (square bottle, black label, man's name) for this purpose.

jburlowski
04-15-2009, 14:44
It's you.........................

OscarV
04-15-2009, 14:55
and the Ripys came out with Ezra Brooks (square bottle, black label, man's name) for this purpose.

I missed that,... The Ripy's created Ezra Brooks?

Hmm,...

independant
04-15-2009, 14:57
Have you tried other EW offerings compared with JD. I have not had JD black label in a long time but I don't remember them tasting the same.

dohidied
04-15-2009, 15:45
JD tastes like bananas to me and EW doesn't.

anyexcuse
04-16-2009, 08:55
absolutely not JD taste like charcoal EW is very good bourbon.
You're right. To me JD has a definite charcoal taste and is kinda weak otherwise. EW has a good bourbon flavor to it. Old Heaven Hill (7 year) is a little cheaper even than EW, and in side by side tasting I think it is a little smoother with about exactly the same taste. Still not exactly the same catagory as WT 101 or OGD BIB, though. YRMV

anyexcuse
04-16-2009, 18:32
Does anyone besides me think that Evan Williams and Jack Daniel's has a similiar taste? I know, EW's a Kentucky bourbon and JD's a charcoal-filtered Tennessee whskey, but nevertheless, I swear, to me EW tastes just like its Tennessee cousin. And don't think my taste buds are completely eroded. I can tell a big difference between Daniel's and Dickel. And, no, Dickel doesn't taste like EW to me in case you're wondering.

Thinking about this further, I know of more than one person who used to drink JD, and now has switched to EW Black because they think EW is just as good, and much cheaper.

Josh
04-17-2009, 06:59
I missed that,... The Ripy's created Ezra Brooks?

Hmm,...

I'm pretty sure. I.W. Berheim: I.W. Harper:: Ezra Ripy: Ezra Brooks