Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
That's interesting; on a recent trip to NY I had an old fashioned that included apple brandy, and it was absolutely amazing. Might have to try this Manhattan. Don't have any Woodford right now, but I'm sure I can find something on the bar to substitute.;)
Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
I like the twist of spice that Creme de Cassis adds.
I've substituted a 1/2 oz of it and reduced the sweet vermouth equally.
Lastly, I love the show that burning orange peel oil adds to the prep and flavor.
(Squeeze a piece of orange peel through a flame and let the burnt oil land on the surface of the cocktail)
Kind of like merging a black dahlia with a manhattan.
Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
I substituted Blanton's for the WR because it was handy, and used some home-aged Apple Brandy. I have to say it was a fantastic drink, but I felt guilty calling it a Manhattan. The whiskey was a little too covered to really call it a Manhattan.
Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
I consider the Manhattan "the king of all cocktails," and try to make a perfectly crafted drink every time they are called for.
Our standard recipe is based in Jackson's bar and cocktail companion, which uses the ratio of 2.5 oz rye to 1 oz sweet vermouth, and angostura bitters, garnished with an maraschino cherry. We modify it by using 2 dashes of blood orange bitters instead of angostura, and for garnish a moonshine-soaked cherry with just a drop or three of the cherried 'shine for good measure. I have yet to also add an orange twist, but plan to try that out soon.
For whiskey, we use either Bulleit rye, or a homemade infusion of Jim Beam rye with apples, cinnamon, and clove. The fruit and spices of the infusion add a bit to the flavor, but don't cover up the whiskey so it still makes a great Manhattan, one that I feel can still bear the name without shame.
Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
Heard someone order the winning WR Manhattan recipe at the bar today.
The addition of apple brandy to whiskey is an interesting combination. I enjoy it in the Diamondback cocktail, which is RittBiB, Laird's BiB and green Chartreuse
Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
I have been experimenting with the apple brandy. For my tastes, it works best in straight bourbon Manhattans. I prefer rye-based Manhattans, the apple flavors tend to muddle and mask the spiciness I really enjoy.
Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
Quote:
Originally Posted by
yountvillewjs
I have been experimenting with the apple brandy. For my tastes, it works best in straight bourbon Manhattans. I prefer rye-based Manhattans, the apple flavors tend to muddle and mask the spiciness I really enjoy.
Try this one:
Diamondback
1.5oz Rittenhouse BiB
.75oz Laird's BiB
.75oz Green Chartreuse
Combine everything in a cocktail glass, add ice and stir well. Strain, garnish as you please, enjoy!
Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
I've messed around with many Diamondback variants since the drink was first made for me a couple years ago, and I have to say the one in the PDT Cocktail Book, while unorthodox, might be my favorite:
2 oz. Rittenhouse BIB
.5 oz. Laird's BIB
.5 oz. Yellow Chartreuse
Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
2 oz Rittenhouse 100
3/4 oz Noilly Prat rouge vermouth
1 splash Fee Brothers Orange Bitters
5 or 6 Large ice cubes
Shake violently for about a minute. You have to really get the air in there. You need large ice cubes so they don't break up and water it down too much.
Strain over 2 large clear ice cubes and garnish with an orange slice. Even better, a blood orange slice.
Re: Well Crafted Manhattan Contest
Quote:
Originally Posted by
LongBeachScott
2 oz Rittenhouse 100
3/4 oz Noilly Prat rouge vermouth
1 splash Fee Brothers Orange Bitters
5 or 6 Large ice cubes
Shake violently for about a minute. You have to really get the air in there. You need large ice cubes so they don't break up and water it down too much.
Strain over 2 large clear ice cubes and garnish with an orange slice. Even better, a blood orange slice.
I'll do it, but it's against my religion to "shake" a manhattan. And it is further a sin to shake "violently".