2011 William Larue Weller
While I'm happy folks appreciate the SB ORVW 15/107 that I have (thanks to a posting here), several of us tasted several ORVW 15's side-by-side and Wade had a Lawrenceburg that I think most of rated the hands down winner.
I've had 2010, 11 & 12 Lot B, 10/107, 2012 WLW, Weller 12 and one glass of PVW 23. The best I've had is 2011 PVW 20.
Can't believe I'm the first to post this, but Louisville bottled Weller Centennial is at the top of my list. I'd trade all my Parker's 10 for a couple more bottles of Centennial!
I would probably have to say some ORVW 15's, and some Pappy 15's and dusty OWA's.
It might just be nostalgia, but the best bottle of wheated bourbon I can recall drinking was a Weller 19. WLW 2009 and PHC 10 yr wheated twanged my buds the right way, too. The best wheated bourbon I've tasted recently was thiefed from a 20+ year old barrel of Stitzel-Weller in a rackhouse in Nelson county.
Today the best wheated bourbon I've had is the PHC 10.
When I think about it longer it would be high on the list of all time wheated bourbons that I've had with WLW 117.9 and PVW 15 in the running for top spot.