Michter's 25 Rye. Goes without saying, that when they don't even post the price (and i had a rough idea it'd be $350ish) then i can't afford to ask.
Disclaimer: Some of these that I passed up today I may go back for (still deciding).
JPS 18, batch 6 for $96 (seemed pretty steep to me - had it been a 17, batch 6 - sold!)
Several WTR101 (brought the first one I saw home, left several more out there)
Hirsch 20 yr American Whiskey for $70
A few BMH (NAS) bourbons
And what I'm seriously reconsidering - some BMH 18yr Rye for $94.
If you don't want it GRAB IT FOR ME. ;)
2 HW 16year old Rye $99.00 wondering if I should have?
On the advice of most of SB, I went back and picked up the Hirsch 22 Rye today. =)
Passed on a PHC blend of Mashbills for 119.99. Also a WT Tradition 14 for 99.99. Another WT American Spirit for 146.99 & a HW 21 for 138.99. I did pick up a 2010 FR LE SmB. :-)
That store is really proud of their bourbon! They must run some stores around here too. The Tradition is about right though.