Might be my favorite whisky of all. Just amazingly drinkableQuote:
Originally Posted by DaveOfAtl
Printable View
Might be my favorite whisky of all. Just amazingly drinkableQuote:
Originally Posted by DaveOfAtl
I attended a Diageo sponsored tasting/dinner tonight at the Bourbon House in NOLA. It was more of an "industry" event for bar and restaurant owners, but somehow I got invited. Along with tasting all of the standard whiskys alongside their Distiller's Editions, they gave us a bottle of Oban 14 and a Dalwhinnie 15, with some Oban glasses just for coming.
There was so much undrunk whisky on my table at the end of the night. 1oz to 1.5 oz of 10 different malts x 80 people or so. They had 800 logo embossed Glencairns on hand apparently.
Anyway, half the people admitted they didn't even like scotch. I almost started dumping the Glencairns into a water glass so it didn't go to waste.
Anyway, I was so "fulfilled" by the end of the dinner that I couldn't bring myself to stumble down to the restaurant bar to sample some of their outstanding selections of bourbon. PHC 1st Edition, BMH 16, WT Tribute, and a Vintage 23 all caught my eye. Haven't tried any of those, so I will have to go back.
Perhaps, but I've always been a bit underwhelmed by the filtered, lower proof 'peat monsters.' I liked Alligator and especially Ardbeg Day, but I'm not a big fan of the standard expression.Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveOfAtl
I had some of the standard 12yo awhile back and liked it quite a bit more than the last time I tried it (years and years ago). I've put the 18yo on my list since then, but the fact is that there are just too many scotches in the $70-$80 range that are on my list these days.Quote:
Originally Posted by Trey Manthey
I have the same impression of the Ardbeg 10, and I stated it here in a thread a couple of years ago. SheezeLouise!!! I'm still picking the buckshot out of my arse fired from the angry Ardbeg fans. :D OK, Maybe, it was the term "weenie scotch" that sent 'em over...;) Conversely, the Lag 16 is in my Top 10 All-Time whiskies.Quote:
Originally Posted by AaronWF
A 750 of Canadian Mist, no particular reason, read Davin's review and it sounded like a can't miss mixer. I'm ceasefully surprised at the number of people who view a blended whisky as 'rotgut' when in fact it's equal quality whisky to those aged longer and priced higher.
Quote:
Originally Posted by AaronWF
I will be interested to try it, and I also love Lag 16. What is it about the Ardbeg 10 that falls short IYO? I was also looking at the Uigeadail but didn't want to drop that kind of coin before trying the standard. Maybe I'll crack the 10 tonight.Quote:
Originally Posted by smokinjoe
That Ardbeg 10 is what got me started with my love affair with Scotch - it's like coming home when I take a sip.
That said, nostalgia probably plays a bigger role than I would like to admit in why I like it so much.
Dave, I felt it had little to no mouthfeel. Very thin, particularly compared to the Lag 16. It really wasn't robust, and the peat was muted. It just seemed as if it had been watered down. Whenever I compared it head-to-head with the Lag, the Ardbeg just withered.Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveOfAtl
Tried it last night side by side with the Lag 16. The Ardbeg had good flavor, but it was definitely very thin. Like water. I will have no problem finishing the bottle, but it doesn't hold a candle to the Lag 16. Not sure that was a fair fight, anyway.Quote:
Originally Posted by smokinjoe