Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

**birdman1099** · 10-17-2010, 16:08

Originally Posted by cigarnv

Vintage 17 from 2006..... delicious juice and IMO not of HH origin.....

It has always been my contention that vintage 17 tasted like an older Brown-Foreman product.

And also, Reid, this is the foreign whisky section.

**ebo** · 10-17-2010, 16:51

I just finished the last pour of Bunnahabhain 12. I have to get another bottle of this... very good stuff.

**JamesW** · 10-18-2010, 18:01

Originally Posted by ebo

I just finished the last pour of Bunnahabhain 12. I have to get another bottle of this... very good stuff.

I really enjoyed my last bottle as well. A terrific bargain single malt for about $40.

**AVB** · 11-02-2010, 19:54

My third bottle of the Balvenie Madeira Cask bit the dust tonight.

**JamesW** · 11-03-2010, 16:56

Originally Posted by AVB

My third bottle of the Balvenie Madeira Cask bit the dust tonight.

That has always interested me. Notes?

**AVB** · 11-03-2010, 20:17

I've been meaning to do a review of this but just never got around to it. However, if you like the Portwood 21 you'll like this one too. I think it may even be a shade better.

Originally Posted by JamesW

That has always interested me. Notes?

**Josh** · 11-04-2010, 09:59

I polished off a couple bottles this week. I sadly finished a bottle of Laphroaig Quarter Cask, and a half bottle of Macallan 12. I loved the 1/4 cask, but The Macallan was pretty meh, as the kids say.

For the last few drams out of each, I vatted them together 1:1, and tasted them alongside CB's Peat Monster. The PM was better, but my vatting held it's own!

**The Boozer** · 11-04-2010, 12:59

Originally Posted by Josh

I polished off a couple bottles this week. I sadly finished a bottle of Laphroaig Quarter Cask, and a half bottle of Macallan 12. I loved the 1/4 cask, but The Macallan was pretty meh, as the kids say.

I recall that it was not too long ago that you just bought the 1/4 cask. Man, you went thru that quick! Well, sometime over the holidays you'll have to stop by the house and we'll do a little 1/4 cask and cask strength side x side.

**Megawatt** · 11-05-2010, 08:49

Glendower 8 year old pure malt. I was sad to see it go but at that price replacing it won't be too challenging!

**JamesW** · 11-06-2010, 14:55

Originally Posted by Megawatt

Glendower 8 year old pure malt. I was sad to see it go but at that price replacing it won't be too challenging!

Me thinks it a good value too!

Thread: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Thread Tools

Display

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Re: Which Bottle Have You Laid To Rest?

Similar Threads

So Just How Old IS My Bottle, Anyway?

Posting Permissions