We ended up going with the following:

ER 10/90 (4)
ER 17yr Fall 2006 (1)
EC 12 (5)
KC (7)
Lot B (3)
Pappy 15 (2)
FRSmB (6)

I thought that the ER 17yr was the smoothest of the group...Pappy 15 is the most complex and biggest finish of the group. The more I try FRSmB I think it might be a bit too floral for me...My ranking are there too!