Thought this post (and the comments) on John Hansell's blog was pretty interesting:
Among other things, Hansell mentions:
And Iíll take just about any Evan Williams over their 23 yr. old offering for the export market (too much wood for me).
Most comments discuss scotch bottlings, but there is a clear consensus leaning toward Pappy 15 over Pappy 20 (which I also agree with)
I am a little surprised that no one mentioned Elijah Craig 12 over EC18 (so I'm about to do just that)
Your proposals or comments?