Are any of you apprenhensive or just not ready to open another bottle of "good" bourbon because you know it will be more than you want to spend to replace it?

I have a few bottles of bourbon that, while not overly expensive, I seem to be hard pressed to make myself crack open. I have a bottle of Four Roses Mariage and Single Barrel... a bottle of Bookers and a bottle of Elijah Craig 18. I love them all, but... I find myself enjoying a pour of Jim Beam Black because I just can't bring myself to open the "good stuff" because I don't want to have to replace them.

Anyone else find themselves doing this from time to time?