From my perspective, this isn't a case about dollars to proof, but dollars to drinking enjoyment.
Hands down, the Willett Rye's in the 3-5+yr range some of, if not the best rye on the market for that age bracket. Wonderful rye flavor, perfect neat, holds up with water wonderfully, and great in a cocktail. That is something that most cannot do. They may do one or two at a stretch, but not the trifecta.
And the price is great for what you get, IMHO.
I just hope that they have some more stashed away aging gracefully, I'd love to have some as they get older.