Gordon & MacPhail Recommendations

[DaveOfAtl]

My local store is taking order for Gordon & MacPhail whisky. The list of options is very long. Many are way, way out of my price range. A few of them caught my eye, however, and I was hoping someone may have some experience with the same or similar bottles they could share. I am fairly new to scotch, but I am really getting into it, and would like to broaden my horizons a bit. I haven't found much with internet searching. Here are a few that caught my eye, but the full list is here.

MacPhail Collection;
Caol lla 2000 11 Year Old 61% $109.99
Glenrothes 8 Year Old 43% $49.99
Highland Park 8 Year Old 43% $49.99
Tamdhu 8 Year Old 43% $49.99


Smith's Glenlivet 15 Year Old 43% $87.99 G
Smith's Glenlivet 15 Year Old 46% $93.99
Smith's Glenlivet 21 Year Old 43% $139.99
Speymalt Macallan 1990 21 Year OLd 43% $139.99
Longmorn Glenlivet 12 Year Old 43% $82.99

Bunnahabhain 11 Year Old 43% $74.99
Coal lla 1999 10 Year Old 46% $78.99
Secret Stills Islay 15 Year Old 45% $84.99

Highland Park 24 Year Old 43% $221.99 Orkney Island

Cask Strength;
Ardmore 1991 16 Year Old 55.2% $119.99 OMG I bet this is friggin amazing!
Benromach 1981 25 Year Old 54.2% $199.99
Mortlach 1998 11 Year Old 57% $136.99
Caol lla 2000 11 Year Old 58.8% $104.99

[Shuboy]

Haven't tried any Gordon & MacPhail bottlings but the cask strength bottles sound good as well as the Highland Park (that 24 year old sounds pricey at that proof though). Mortlach is extremely interesting from what Ralfy has described (he's reviewed several independent bottlings and all were good).

[DaveOfAtl]

Thanks, I appreciate the info.

[DaveOfAtl]

Picked up the Mortlach. Looking forward to trying it out.