Thought this thread could be in the same spirit as the buy / pass-up threads. Often I find myself faced with two or more tempting whiskey choices to add to the collection, but sadly budgeted myself for only one bottle. Hopefully people can add their 2c to make these either-or decisions easier.

I'll start.

Parker's Heritage Cognac at $80
4R Single Barrel Cask Strength at $60 (K&L bottling)