Is it worth $140? Sadly, yes.
Obviously that's an absurd retail price--so high you'd hate to reward that kind of extortionist retailer behavior. But the PHC 1st Ed. is so spectacular, complex and rare, that I'd cave, buy it, and grumble bitterly on the ride home. I've got half a bottle left and wish I had more but it's long gone and almost never comes up for auction.
See if you can push the owner to a slightly less ridiculous $120. That'll practically make it a "bargain."
Every member of LAWS gave it an "A" and rightfully so. http://www.lawhiskeysociety.com/whis...-First-Edition