After wanting to buy a bottle of Rye for quite a while now, i finally bit the Bulliet (see what I did there) and bought a bottle of Bulleit Rye. Wow!!! It is exactly what I've always wanted in a whiskey! I'm glad I took the $29.99 leap of faith. The cherry cola, oak, earth, spice balances so nicely. That is my vote... good luck!
Long time reader, first time poster!