BMH SB or ORVW10/107?

[trumpstylz]

This one's super easy. old rip by a mile.

[LostBottle]

It depends. Do I have to stand in line or beg for the ORVW? If yes, then BMH by a mile...and I don't even like it that much.

[HighInTheMtns]

Making the following assumptions: ORVW is available at a reasonable ($35 or so) price, and is sitting on a shelf without me having to jump through any hoops.

With those conditions met I would buy it over any other spirit of similar price. Partly because it's very good, partly because it's fairly unique among things in that price range, and largely because I know I enjoy it, I know my friends enjoy it, and I wouldn't know when I'll see it again. Not because it's any kind of holy grail. I don't have a deep bunker of ORVW; even so, I won't go to great lengths to find it and I CERTAINLY won't overpay for it.

As for BMH, I've passed on it in favor of all kinds of things. Maybe I should give it a shot sometime but it doesn't seem to be too loved here.

[Clavius]

Can't remember if I've ever had the BMH SB... Eh, I'd go with ORVW 10/107 regardless. One of my absolute favorites.

[Tennessee Dave]

I am in the ORVW camp lock, stock and barrel.

[docbible]

I have to go along with the others and would purchase the orvw if not insanely priced. Wheaters are my preference and the hoopla surrounding anything vw will only drive up the price and decrease availability. tim

[jcg9779]

Another ORVW 10/107 vote here as well.

[gblick]

ORVW 10/107 for me too, please..

[mosugoji64]

Oh, what the hell, I'll throw in a vote for ORVW. It's pointless now, but there you have it.

[Barclay Beach]

Gimme the Rip! Never been more disappointed with a bourbon than BMH.