BMH SB or ORVW10/107?

[Josh]

I'm going to be a contrarian here and say Old Rip 107.

[Ejmharris]

I have a have a BMH open right now and I referred to it as a Jekyll and Hyde bourbon for me. Sometimes I like it and others it tastes like grazing on a grassy plain.

[squire]

Any Van Winkle over any Black Maple Hill.

[Rutherford]

I'm not a big fan of wheaters or the Van Winkle line, so ORVW 10/107. Still. BMH isn't all that good, and ORVW 10 is one of the best wheaters I've had; I personally prefer it to anything Weller or PVW.

[BradleyC]

Any Van Winkle over any Black Maple Hill.

What about the Black Maple Hills that were bottled by Van Winkle? I'd take those over 10/107 I think.

[squire]

Only Julian & Co. know what was placed in whose bottles and until I know for sure I'll take the stuff he puts his family name on.

[BradleyC]

Only Julian & Co. know what was placed in whose bottles and until I know for sure I'll take the stuff he puts his family name on.

Good point. I still won't say no to any Lawrenceburg BMH or 2006 WLW if I happen to stumble across any (not likely though).

[squire]

Bradley there's very little I will say no to if someone else is pouring.

[BradleyC]

Bradley there's very little I will say no to if someone else is pouring.

I hear you on that.

[compliance]

This was a thrashing, but I'm piling on anyway. ORVW, not even close.