We had some at a restaurant in Lexington last July, and it was fantastic.
Bought 2 sixes at a liquor store to take home, and the bottles were just ho-hum.
Must have been the ambiance.
Vosgar the best one to me is Founder's Backwoods Bastard. Only release in limited quantities in the fall.
Are you sure you bought the same beer? Kentucky Ale/Alltech's bourbon barrel ale is only offered in 4 packs. Schlafly has a bourbon barrel ale that is similar and offered in 6 packs.