Thanks folks, I really appreciate all the tips. I think I may have been taking the Binny's online search too literally. I do not get down to the South Loop much, I was at the Lincoln Park and Lakeview Binny's in the last month and did not see it.
Unfortunately, I saw a good price on Weller Special Reserve and grabbed it instead. Cracked it this weekend and was not blown away. Because I don't have a ton of money, I'm gonna have to get through this and some other bottles first. I think Maker's Mark is better than Weller SR--I messed up.