Of stuff generally available, I'd go with the Rock Hill Farms.
So it's really that good, eh?

At $42/bottle, I've been having trouble convincing myself to give it a try, but with Tim's description ("It is the most luxurious bourbon I have ever tasted."), I'm seriously tempted to go for it anyway.

I'll just have to schedule a trip to the store to coincide with my next moment of weakness!