You're probably right, it wasn't exactly a controlled tasting and my palate was all over the place.
On the sunday we were sat in temple bar and had 11 pints of guinness

and 11 measures of whisky

(from a selection of over 200) and the most memorable thing about the Bunnahabhain was the taste of dark chocolate (probably enhanced by the chocolatey notes in Irish guinness), removing that and comparing it with the subsequent whiskey may be subject to a little error. I'd agree that the Connemarra was pretty unique and I'll definatley be on the look out for more, though range in Irish whisky has only just become common here since the troubles so I may have to wait awhile.
Luckily I had the Midleton VR first.
