just one bottle?

[FlashPuppy]

Easy, Weller 12!

As long as it one of the four BOTY's.....

[CrispyCritter]

At Chicago prices, it would be one of:

• Sazerac Jr. Rye
• WT Rye
• Weller 12/90
• Weller 7/107
• OGD 114
• ETL

Naaaaah, one bottle is too few! Really, there are a whole lot of sub-$30, and even sub-$20 bottles that are Good Stuff. I could add AAA 10 year, Jim Beam Black, Old Fitzgerald BIB, George Dickel #12 (Tennessee), Rittenhouse BIB Rye, standard WT 101, OGD BIB, ERSB 10... you get the picture.

[fitzharry]

I would definitely have to say that my choice is Old Grand-Dad 114...or ORVW 10/107.

[EvanB]

Hands down...Makers Mark

[Father&Son]

Booker's (...or two bottles of Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel for the same price! )

[SBOmarc]

ETL and it was a tough choice!

[Ubertaster]

At this point in my tasting carrier I would choose Saz Jr.

bj

[mozilla]

My choice for the rye category: Wild Turkey
" ........" bourbon: Ridgemont Reserve 1792

[BourbonJoe]

Four Roses Single Barrel or the Small Batch.
Joe

[tmas]

ORVW 10yr 107. A grand bourbon, and the label is fun to contemplate after a couple of rounds. Tom V