All Activity

Just got this. Supposed to be a sherry bomb, something I like. Cask strength and fairly young (7 years old), but I often like younger single malts that are less woody and still rich flavored. I am fine with older single malts as well, but a younger age does not scare me at all. I'll report once I try it. Very excited.

Brain fart. I was thinking 4R and moved it to OF. But damn that BB was good!

Just picked this up. Excited to try it. Not a big Irish Whiskey guy as they are generally lighter/milder in the flavor department. However, rum and PX Sherry finish got me interested as did cask strength. I was getting a scotch I was interested in from the same shop and figured I'd give it a go. $70 for a cask strength Irish Whiskey is good, especially if it is a good pour. I have The Wild Rover, by High N' Wicked and it is good, but did not blow me away. I felt it didn't really know what it wanted to be and the PX notes are not strong. I will try the Killowen in the next couple of days and report.

Agreed.

I have considered the 15 year variety too but there's quite a price jump between the 13 and 15 year. $250 for the 15 year seems high to me.

I burned off some brush in the bonfire last night. Unfortunately I have much more to do. It really has piled up and without my boys around it has gotten ahead of me. Anyway I took a bottle of Peerless Rye with me that was a store pick from 5 years ago. It has a wonderful spearmint note in the mid palate. A couple of neighbors saw the flames and smoke so it turned into an evening of hotdogs, chips and s’mores with rye. Happy FRyeday!

I know it's off topic, but I was able to find the Old Forester Single Barrel, Barrel Proof. I'm headed out in a bit to pick it up. I don't much care for Rye, but do like higher proof, so will tee this and the Sagamore Double Oaked this weekend.

My bottle of Knob Creek 18 arrives this week. Of course a 21 year variety is forthcoming so depending on price, I'll look to add that to my collection as I enjoy Knob Creek and find it to be fairly priced.

Thanks Mal. I forgot about that one. Bookers in CA have always been shelf turds. Even now with the price settling at $89-99 they languish on the shelves. Good for me because I always have one open.

I knew that extra $20 would come with a steep grading curve!

The BB is 10-12 years old and bottled at 90 something proof, changes by release. It seems a drier profile compared to other versions of OF. I get tannin like strong tea, dry wood like cedar cigar box. At low 90 something proof, and not much sweetness, it can feel sort of thin. It's ok, but not my favorite in the OF line up.

https://www.bookersbourbon.com/bourbons/2018-02-backyard-bbq From what I remember, it was a tasty batch. Beam had recently hiked the price but it was still easily obtainable here in MA.

Yeah....it's great, but so is the standard 101...not worth the extra $$$...

Yup and, after the initial pour, it's very good but not much better, (if it all), than the standard offering. I guess that I can to do a blind SBS, but I already know that it's not worth the extra $$. I don't regret the purchase, but will not be replacing these...

Agreed... but I opted for the KC18 that day instead, because the 12 year is ubiquitous, and the 18 not so much.

Enjoying OGD 114 watching the rain. Going to move onto some Bombergers 2025

I think you can always post a new bottle (of any kind) here, or else in the Rye forum. Equally appropriate Nice looking photo, and a really nice looking glass there. Happy fRyeday to you sir!

I’m always a bit confused about where to post the opening of a rye. This thread is in General Bourbon, but the title is “ What bottle did you open in 2025.” And there isn’t an opening thread over in Rye. Anyway, here goes. Good fortune came my way and I procured this JD Rye BiB at a very reasonable price. After sipping on it over the last few hours, I’d say, it is a purchase for me @$35. In the rye forum, I recommend to pick it up at $25. ( I really don’t like to spend other folks money.) For me though, $35 is right. I like it! Cheers

True, that story sounds familiar; seems like I've read or heard that somewhere. With 20/20 hindsight now, it's amazing to think how much stellar whiskey must have been lost as blends into Seagram's Seven.

Sipping on an new on for me. JD BiB Rye. I like it. For me, I think Jack Daniel’s does rye better than Tennessee whiskey/bourbon. I say this one is a buy, especially if you find it $25 or lower. Oh yeah, and Happy FRyeday!

You should definitely crack your Booker's 25! That's still the best Booker's bourbon I've ever tasted. But I missed scoring my own bottle of that one back then by about a month. (Timing is everything in life, lol). I have no excuse for not yet cracking the Booker's 30th however. I need to find an excuse to remedy that.

We are still in the pre celebratory phase. I don’t think they have a backyard batch. The closest thing would be the Lumberyard Batch. If I do use Bookers to officially celebrate I’ll probably crack my Bookers 25.

I've only had OF100 Rye neat. And I've had a lot of it. Once while on vacation in Florida, the beach bar didn't have any good bourbon options but they had OF Rye. I had my share of those neat . Personally, I can't imagine ever adding water or even ice to this particular bottle; I wouldn't expect to work very well. I'm ashamed to admit that I've never even tried OF rye in a home cocktail (but I think I've had it an Old Fashioned before at a restaurant/bar before IIRC). I don't make a lot of cocktails at home, but I should definitely try this one myself sometime. I've had such good luck with Rittenhouse in an Old Fashioned, that I sometimes just get stuck in that rut.