All Activity

With regular ER being at 10 years I think your notion of something in between that and 17 makes a lot of sense.

I haven't responded to this yet because I keep forgetting to reach for my open bottle to have it fresh on my memory but I do find it interesting to see multiple people comment on getting a mint flavor. The primary reason why I don't drink more rye than the most of you is that I get the mint flavor most of the time and don't like it very much. My palate needs to be in a very particular spot so I don't get the mint too strongly. My memory of the OF rye is that I don't get the mint on it so now I'm really intrigued for the re-taste.

I have not. That's not a bad idea. Old Forester has some great and for the most part affordable options

nothing better than playoff hockey! I remember when my home town had a hockey team. Unfortunately, they left several years ago. I sure do miss them

Excellent. I was at the F1 event over the weekend and tried this for the first time. Not a bad bourbon. I'm not a fan of rye's unless I mix up an old fashioned, but this one is worth $60 for the bottle.

Have you tried the standard 100 proof version? (the subject of this thread) It's on shelves everywhere and always less than 30 bucks.

I have been drinking some higher end bourbons from my collection as of late but had a taste for a good old fashioned. My wife bought me a bartesian cocktail machine for Christmas and I mixed up an old fashioned with Woodford Reserve Rye, and the imported italian cherries, and orange peel. It was a very nice change of pace.

Have you ever added bourbon to your chili?

I find many have a dislike for Dickel. Some referring to it as the Dickel funk. I have the 15 year and found it to be enjoyable.

I've seen that posted among several SBrs. I'm a Dickel fan but never went for the 15yr. The initial BiB to me was a bit too oakey so I try to stay under that threshold. The latest 12yr BiB I think is fantastic, such an underrated pour that sits on shelves while the taters clamor to overpay for whatever FB/Insta tells them they need.

I had nearly forgotten that I still had it; was in the back of the bunker for a long time. It was really quite flavorful, more than I had recalled. When it was released, it was the focus of a somewhat hokey marketing effort, thus the "aged in Stitzel-Weller Barrels" label.

We'll be in Nashville for a few days after Christmas. We're definitely doing JD, but the tour company offers a combination tour that includes JD & Uncle Nearest. To anyone whose been, is the Uncle Nearest worth visiting? Please bear in mind that we've toured a shit-ton of distilleries in Kentucky. JD has been on the bucket list for years. Not sure about Uncle Nearest. I've only ever tried one of their whiskeys, and wasn't overly impressed. Thanks!

I've read before that the 18 yr Marriage is a blend from 3 different Mashbills. I would assume that means MB 1, MB 2, and the Wheated Mashbill from the Weller/Pappy line, but I figure they have a plethora of experimental mashbills so maybe it's some other combination of three. I hadn't considered that it might be a rotational or varying release...that could be an interesting twist. It could be as you suggested, ~10 yr to 12 yr old and BiB, so kind of like BT's version of Old Forester 1924.

Who, that’s interesting. So it seems you’d be content with saving the money and going with a few bottles of the select. I came to the same conclusion with Woodford Reserve Double Double Oaked. I could buy no less than 2 store pick of the double oaked and still have money left over

I am not crazy about rye whiskey. I usually mix it in an old fashioned. Seems I lost an opportunity. Will look again

“Can you tell what the Rock is pouring?”

I said goodbye to this one tonight. While I enjoyed the bottle, I honestly didn’t find it any better than most of the Russell‘s Reserve Private Select’s that I’ve had. This is one I probably will not buy again, considering the price tag compared to the private barrels.

I’ve only come across this bottle twice and I snatched a bottle both times. It’s outstanding.

Very underrated rye that is good neat, over ice, or in an Old Fashioned. I usually get mint on the palate when consuming this as well. It can’t be beat for the price.

Any details about that Jefferson's?

As is Woodford with some of there special releases. I think this might be the future of all btls (700ml). I hope not. Business wise it makes sense but as a customer, I DONT LIKE IT. I think we will get less juice and pay the same or more for it.

This is my favorite thread. My latest contributions. Pat

Even better as I do enjoy those too. Thank you for the clarification

This game is a nail-biter. C'mon Caps!!

Do you know what the mash bill was for that 18 year Marriage? I didn't have a bottle of that one and not sure. If it's BT mashbill #1 then an 18 year makes no sense, because that is the mashbill for ER17. That's why I'm guessing an age statement in the middle range (say 10-12 yr) ... something that is not hyper-aged like ER17 but yet significantly older than regular CEHT. They could also make the new EH Taylor BTAC bottle something that varies year to year (or even experimental like some CEHT special releases have been) just to keep the taters sufficiently in a constant frenzy.