This over That

[cbsmokin]

I have a thread idea, maybe it has been done before, but why not do it again. Give me a list of your this over that.

For example maybe you say Bookers over Basil Haydens or something along that line.

I think this could be helpful to newer people (like myself) when considering different things to try. Include all price ranges.

To make it easy you can just type with a slash to make a list.

This / That

Let's hear it.

[Vange]

A few off the top of my head

Elmer T Lee vs ER10

RHF vs Blanton's

Pappy 15 vs Pappy 20

Bookers vs Bakers

WTRB vs WTKS

[funknik]

I love this idea, but it sounds like what I do every time I go to the liquor store. Most of the time I'm thinking in terms of what is a better value (i.e. less money) for a similar or superior bottle (in my own opinion, of course), but sometimes, what's a better pour in a similar price point (again, IMO). Here are some easy ones:

Elijah Craig 12 / Knob Creek

WL Weller Special Reserve / Maker's Mark

Wild Turkey Rye 101 / Russel's Reserve Rye

Ancient Ancient Age 10yr / Eagle Rare Single Barrel 10/90

George Dickel No.12 / Jack Daniel's

Wild Turkey Rare Breed / Blanton's

Baker's / Booker's

Van Winkle Lot 'B' / Pappy 20

[funknik]

A few off the top of my head

Elmer T Lee vs ER10

RHF vs Blanton's

Pappy 15 vs Pappy 20

Bookers vs Bakers

WTRB vs WTKS

That's funny, we went opposite on the Booker's and the Baker's.....what's your stand on Candlestick Makers?

[fishnbowljoe]

All bourbon / ice. :slappin: Joe

[sotnsipper]

All bourbon / ice. :slappin: Joe

Love your idea:lol:!!! Going on that idea here are a couple.

Ice over Coke

Neat over Ice

And another one.

Anything 100+ proof over and 80 proofer.

[fishnbowljoe]

I hope I get to meet you at the KBF Ty. Not everyone laughs at my jokes. I appreciate it. Joe

[Blitz]

Weller Antique over Makers

Buffalo Trace over Elijah Craig 12

Knob Creek over Woodford Reserve

Pappy 15 over Pappy 20

Bookers over just about anything

Looking at my list, appearantly I'll take BT and Beam Small Batch against the field. Didn't realize.

[OscarV]

I love this idea, but it sounds like what I do every time I go to the liquor store. Most of the time I'm thinking in terms of what is a better value (i.e. less money) for a similar or superior bottle (in my own opinion, of course), but sometimes, what's a better pour in a similar price point (again, IMO). Here are some easy ones:

Elijah Craig 12 / Knob Creek

WL Weller Special Reserve / Maker's Mark

Wild Turkey Rye 101 / Russel's Reserve Rye

Ancient Ancient Age 10yr / Eagle Rare Single Barrel 10/90

George Dickel No.12 / Jack Daniel's

Wild Turkey Rare Breed / Blanton's

Baker's / Booker's

Van Winkle Lot 'B' / Pappy 20

Ah, you learn well young man, I agree with everyone.

[funknik]

Ah, you learn well young man, I agree with everyone.

Thank You, sir.....the support is appreciated.

[callmeox]

I hope I get to meet you at the KBF Ty. Not everyone laughs at my jokes. I appreciate it. Joe

Stick around late enough at the Gazebo and you will get to see this in person. :slappin:

I'll counter with

Russel's Reserve Rye / WT 101 Rye

The WT rye gives me a freshly punched in the throat feeling every time I try it again.

[ILLfarmboy]

The WT rye gives me a freshly punched in the throat feeling every time I try it again.

What's the matter.....don't you like that freshly punched in the throat feeling?

wuss :grin:

[Attila]

fishnets over nylon hose

[Lost Pollito]

Stick around late enough at the Gazebo and you will get to see this in person. :slappin:

I'll counter with

Russel's Reserve Rye / WT 101 Rye

The WT rye gives me a freshly punched in the throat feeling every time I try it again.

What you doin to get punched in the throat? Maybe to much of that 101 makes you a lil wild?

[Lost Pollito]

fishnets over nylon hose

I'll take the fishnets.

[fishnbowljoe]

I'll take anything I can get. Thanks Scott. Love you like a brother. Joe

[cbsmokin]

Anyone care to put all their over / unders in one long chain? In other words rank em how you would drink them all sitting in front of you? I bet it's harder than you think.

And to add to the off topic ...

Thong / Full Coverage

Real / Silicone or Saline

Porsche / Corvette

[spun_cookie]

Wemon/me

Me/Wemon

Could not resist :yum: :crazy:

[sailor22]

motorcycles/cars

Ducati/Honda

Bourbon/Scotch

neat/rocks

experience/youth

van winkle/Jim Beam

Wild Turkey/Jack Daniels

sweet/dry

comfortable/thin

rum/gin

armagnac/cognac

[kickert]

Buffalo Trace / Heaven Hill

Weller 12 / Lot B

EC12 / EC18

Rittenhouse Rye / WT Rye

Old Charter / AAA

[EricABQ]

EC 12 over 18

Pappy 15 over 20

Kentucky Spirit over Rare Breed

[ggilbertva]

Weller Antique / Weller SR

WT 8 yr 101 / WT 101 current

Blantons Gold /Blantons Original

AAA 10 year / ER 10/90

Pleasure / pain

Laughter / tears

Corvette / tricycle

Pat on the back / sharp poke in the eye

[ILLfarmboy]

Rare breed / 101

WTRR 101 / RR90

Weller Antique / Maker's Mark

Booker's / any other current Beam

WT Rye / WTRR 90

OGD BIB / Bulleit

Sazerac Rye / Beam Rye

[smokinjoe]

Baby Saz over RRR

OGD 114 over Booker's

Evan Williams over Jim Beam

EC18 over EC12

Pappy 15 over Pappy 20

Lot B over Pappy 20

Maker's over Woodford

ER 10yr SB over ER 101

VOB 100 proof over EW 100 proof

BHC OCPR 13 over BHC Weller Centennial

Dickel over Daniel's

Vya Sweet over Noilly Sweet

Infiniti over Lexus

Ford Pickup over Chevy Pickup

Bud over Miller

95 F over 35 F

Lo rider boy shorts "shorties" over thongs (No, not for me )

Centerlines over Cragar S/S

Omaha over Hold 'em

Gazebo Table over Sampler

Wood Bat over Aluminum Bat

Aerosmith over Rolling Stones

Robin Meade/Christi Paul :bowdown: (Push :yum:)

Ginger over Mary Ann

Jeannie over Ginger

Dodgers over Angels

White Sox over Cubs

Giants over A's

Mets/Yankees (2 wrongs don't make a right )

[funknik]

Let's see how far we've come in almost a year:

AAA 10yr > RHF > ETL > Blanton's

Buffalo Trace > ERSB10/90 > OC10

WTKS = RB > WT101 > RR90

Weller12 > OWA > WLW SR > MM > any current Old Fitz

WTRye101 = Sazerac > Ritt BIB > ri1 > RR Rye 90 > JB Rye

OGD114 > Baker's > Booker's > KC > OGD

4R Yellow > 4Rsmb

EWSB > EC12 = Mckenna BIB

(and, as an afterthought, if I'm out at a bar & really want a whiskey here's my preference (the selection sucks here!): Black Bush = WT101 > KC > OGD86 > MM)

I like this thread, so I thought I'd give it a bump so some of the newer members could chime in.