New/Current Pappy 15 vs PHC wheater

[awachatz]

The only thing about PHC 10 is that it did not hold up well on crushed ice.

I made this mistake when drinking my first bottle of PHC 10. Couldn't agree more.

[hectic1]

I agree with Bob but would go further to say that the PHC wheater is better than any of the recent WLWs. (I got some grief for saying this when the PHC 2010 first came out.)

Better than Pappy 15? The older, clearly S-W Pappy --- no. The more recent PVW 15? Face to face: I dunno... In a blind tasting, maybe.

Yes folks, The 2010 PHC is that good.

Glad someone around here agrees with me John!

I tried to secure a couple more PHC 2010 bottles today that had been sitting on the shelf for months with no interest...they were gone. I've decided that this site is a blessing and a curse as the number of lurkers here make it hard to buy good bourbon over a period of time...you have to get the amount you want when you first see it. I'm gonna start posting how good Maker's Mark is...there is plenty of that stuff on the shelves!

[wine65]

I love the PHC 2010 but what I find funny is how it al of a sudden seems so highly sought after. Is it a factor of it becoming difficult to obtain? It sat on the shelves in Atlanta for almost a year. Unrelated question what's with 107 proof why not 100 or 105?

[Special Reserve]

I've been signing the praises for PHC 10 for a long time. At $80/bottle it is a high priced bourbon and may be too high for the more casual bourbon enthusiast.

[trumpstylz]

Unrelated question what's with 107 proof why not 100 or 105?

The higher the better. You can always bring the proof down, but you can never bring it back up.

[trumpstylz]

I love the PHC 2010 but what I find funny is how it al of a sudden seems so highly sought after.

I think it's high price kept it from being "sought after" for a while, but it is just now starting to really disappear off of the shelves, and that's why its a big deal now.

[RyanL]

I think it's high price kept it from being "sought after" for a while, but it is just now starting to really disappear off of the shelves, and that's why its a big deal now.

[MacinJosh]

I can't believe how many PHC 2010 threads there are now. It's everywhere!

Let's all start posting how AMAZING Old Fitz Prime is!!!!

Ready....set....go!!!!!!

Josh

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[awachatz]

This past weekend we tried both the new Pappy 15 and the PHC from 2010 and the consensus was that the PHC from 2010 won all the way.

Unfortunately I only have a bottle and a half now and cannot find any more.

Best regards, tony

[StraightNoChaser]

Conducted the same test today and the results were identical. Very disappointed with this year's PVW 15. It was not worth all the trouble to acquire it. I would have preferred another bottle of JPS 17.

Or spend double the effort, half the price, and get a dusty Weller Centennial... at least that's been my strategy the past few months

[RyanL]

Or spend double the effort, half the price, and get a dusty Weller Centennial... at least that's been my strategy the past few months

If we only all lived in TX.

[birdman1099]

I can't believe how many PHC 2010 threads there are now. It's everywhere!

Let's all start posting how AMAZING Old Fitz Prime is!!!!

Ready....set....go!!!!!!

Josh

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I actually bought a new bottle of OFP..... it is amazing.... Tastes just like the PHC, but a bit better.....:grin:

[hectic1]

I actually bought a new bottle of OFP..... it is amazing.... Tastes just like the PHC, but a bit better.....:grin:

I'm so glad HH finally decided to fix the Old Fitz line...seems like dumping the remaining PHC 2010 into the Old Fitz bottles was a GREAT fix!

[trumpstylz]

How can you tell which the new/good bottlings of the old fitz are?

[MacinJosh]

I'm so glad HH finally decided to fix the Old Fitz line...seems like dumping the remaining PHC 2010 into the Old Fitz bottles was a GREAT fix!

EXACTLY!!!! This is AMAZING JUICE!!!! I can't believe no one knows about this!!!! What an amazingly well kept secret!!!!!

It's like Stizel-Weller all over again only BETTER!!!! Heaven Hill has struck gold with this one.....

Josh

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[T Comp]

Hey guys...He's making a list/ And checking it twice/He's going to find out who's naughty and nice .

[autiger23]

My sarcasm meter must be turned off cause today being off for christmas I can't tell if yall are serious or not about the OFP.

Is it really that good?

[STLbourbon]

Seriously, is new OFP really good stuff?

B

[trumpstylz]

Seriously, is new OFP really good stuff?

B

I'm 99.9% sure they're f@#king with us.

[autiger23]

I'm 99.9% sure they're f@#king with us.

That's where i was leaning but since i can't hear it in their voice I was giving them that .1%.