Jump to content

Trying my first Pappy - Advice requested on expression and comparator

boneuphtoner

By boneuphtoner
in General Bourbon Discussion

 Share
This topic has been inactive for at least 365 days, and is now closed. Please feel free to start a new thread on the subject! 

Recommended Posts

boneuphtoner Enthusiast

boneuphtoner

Posted
Posted

Hi Folks,

I'm getting ready to try me some Pappy for the very first time. While travelling, I have found a bar that has the 15 and 20 year expressions available....I certainly prefer to try a tasting in a bar before I commit funds and the effort some of you people do to get some of this stuff! I have a couple of questions questions:

  • Which of the two expressions would you try first? I'm going to try either or, but not both.
  • What would your comparator for these be? The most logical ones based on distillery, proof, recipe, etc. would be OWA for the 15, and Weller 12 for the 20. I know some of you may not believe in using a comparator, but since I'm still a relative newbie, having a comparator really helps me sort out what I'm experiencing. It should be noted that I've tried both OWA and Weller 12 several times, and since the Pappy products are certainly related to these in proof and recipe (they're all BT based wheaters!), they make the most logial sense to me as comparators.
  • Or should I compare the Pappy with one of my two very favorite bourbons? I like OWA and Weller 12 very much, they are nearly my favorites, but for me EC12 and ETL are the tops.

Thanks very much for any advice/suggestions you can offer!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
bad_scientist Connoisseur

bad_scientist

Posted
Posted

A few points:

1. Check the whiskey levels in the bottles. If you haven't done this before, it's helpful to let wheaters sit for several months in the bottle with some air exposure. You might be shocked to see how much of a difference it makes. If the levels are pretty high, or if the bottles were opened recently, the taste won't have opened up that much. It's not something that you can duplicate fully by letting it sit in the glass for a while.

2. Why not compare them to each other? Pappy 15, at least the new one, is BT, while Pappy 20 is still SW. As for your suggestions, both sets should be instructive. The wheaters are pretty bland, compared to the Pappies, but you're right, they do have the same origin as the Pappy 15 (not the 20). EC and ETL have much more of a rye presence than a lot of bourbons, and of course the Pappies have no rye, so you might be able to compare the rye spiciness in those to the wheat semi-spiciness in the PVWs.

3. Meridian Pint in DC has plenty of PVW23 for you to try.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
boneuphtoner Enthusiast

boneuphtoner

Posted
  • Author
Posted
Why not compare them to each other?

Mostly because I've never had any of the Pappy's before and I'd like to appreciate the difference (really I'm looking for the magnitude of the difference) between one of those and a comparator that I've tried before. When I do comparisons I try not to do more than two tastings at a time because I lose sensitivity beyond that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
clingman71 Connoisseur

clingman71

Posted
Posted


If the 15 is an '11, it is BT distilled VW. I would go with the 20 first. SW is in finite supply. There is no guarantee that you'll have the opportunity to drink SW bourbon in the future. While not easy to find, there is no reason that you won't have many opportunitirs to drink the BT distilled VW.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
bad_scientist Connoisseur

bad_scientist

Posted
Posted
Mostly because I've never had any of the Pappy's before and I'd like to appreciate the difference (really I'm looking for the magnitude of the difference) between one of those and a comparator that I've tried before. When I do comparisons I try not to do more than two tastings at a time because I lose sensitivity beyond that.

Personally, I like to compare wheat to wheat. On paper, I'd say pair a non-wheater with one of the Pappies, but in practice, I never do that. When I do a tasting of two or more wheaters, I notice the big differences with the first sip, and with subsequent sips I start picking up on the striking similarities.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
SMOWK Disciple

SMOWK

Posted
Posted

I say drink it and see if you like it. You probably will. The only real way to find out is blind. It's amazing what a bottle in the hand will do to your head.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
RyanL Advanced Taster

RyanL

Posted
Posted

I was at a bat in LA last night that had PVW15 for $25 and Lot B for $30 which was hilarious. They have very few value pours...well basically none other than ordering a cocktail with lower priced but still great bourbon based on the fact the bartenders make amazing cocktails with bourbon...compared to ur regular bar u would laugh with embarrassment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
sob0728 Enthusiast

sob0728

Posted
Posted
I was at a bat in LA last night that had PVW15 for $25 and Lot B for $30 which was hilarious. They have very few value pours...well basically none other than ordering a cocktail with lower priced but still great bourbon based on the fact the bartenders make amazing cocktails with bourbon...compared to ur regular bar u would laugh with embarrassment.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
thezenone Taster

thezenone

Posted
Posted

Some places must just have misprints that don't get caught. I had dinner a week ago where they had Glenlivet 12 year for $11 and Macallan 18 year for $10. Guess what I had a glass of?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
keith18 Taster

keith18

Posted
Posted
Look at the ridiculousness of the drink menu from Craftsteak in Las Vegas (page 91-92 have rye/bourbon). The Maker's 46 is $25 and the PHC Golden Anniversary is $23. What?!?

http://www.mgmgrand.com/restaurants/Craft_Wine_List.pdf

I probably should just keep this info to myself and go have a pour of the PHC Golden Anniversary when I am in Vegas in May.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Special Reserve Guru

Special Reserve

Posted
Posted
My local watering hole has the 23 year @ $20 for a 2 Oz pour.

Sent from my PG86100 using Tapatalk

jk where is that?

Will

Link to comment
Share on other sites
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.

  I accept