Which one would you choose?

[weller_tex]

Going to shopping this weekend to get one good bottle.

Which one would you get? (these are all new for me)

E.H. Taylor Tornado

Vintage Bourbon 17 year

Willett 8 year/121 proof

Four Roses Single Barrel (not the LE)

PHC 5th Edition

Garrison Bros. Texas Whiskey

[Tico]

I'd go EH Tornado or PHC 5th. I do like the Vintage 17 but it seems widely available where as the Tornado and PHC are more limited.

[StraightNoChaser]

Vintage Bourbon 17 year

Four Roses Single Barrel (not the LE)

PHC 5th Edition

I'd pick up any of these three. Most likely I would get the 4R since I'm currently out. Got a bottle of the Vb17 already and the PHC is a tad pricey.

[bgageus]

I would eliminate the 4R and Garrison form the list. You can get the 4R anytime, and Garrison is a micro, not saying its bad, I actually have high hopes, but is young and expensive and relatively easy to get in TX. I have wanted to head to Nye for a visit.

[weller_tex]

Yeah the Garrison is expensive. All the bars that carry it are a good ways from me, and hard to have time to go try it at a bar.

[weller_tex]

I'd pick up any of these three. Most likely I would get the 4R since I'm currently out. Got a bottle of the Vb17 already and the PHC is a tad pricey.

[mosugoji64]

The VB 17 is tempting since it's a wheater..

[jcg9779]

EH Taylor Tornado or PHC 5

[StraightNoChaser]

Yeah the Garrison is expensive. All the bars that carry it are a good ways from me, and hard to have time to go try it at a bar.

It's not just expensive. It's awful bourbon.

[Bmac]

PHC 5th all the way.

[bgageus]

It's not just expensive. It's awful bourbon.

That's good to know, I bought a bottle on my last trip to TX and was going to open it with my TX friend, maybe I will just gift it to him... or sell it on ebay:slappin:

First time crossing threads, I hope that life as I know it does not stop and every molecule of my body explode at the speed of light.

[StraightNoChaser]

That's good to know, I bought a bottle on my last trip to TX and was going to open it with my TX friend, maybe I will just gift it to him... or sell it on ebay:slappin:

Bootleggin' Texas whiskey

[weller_tex]

It's not just expensive. It's awful bourbon.

That's too bad...

[AaronWF]

I would probably go with the PHC cognac. I only briefly tasted the Tornado, but I've spent quite a bit of time with the PHC and I... covet it.

You gotta get both.

[weller_tex]

I would probably go with the PHC cognac. I only briefly tasted the Tornado, but I've spent quite a bit of time with the PHC and I... covet it.

You gotta get both.

Both would be nice, but not in the budget. I have certainly read good things about it..the PHC I mean.

[wine65]

Lots of great choices, I'd go with EH Taylor Tornado as its limited and I really enjoyed it.

[Ejmharris]

Going to shopping this weekend to get one good bottle.

Which one would you get? (these are all new for me)

E.H. Taylor Tornado

Vintage Bourbon 17 year

Willett 8 year/121 proof

Four Roses Single Barrel (not the LE)

PHC 5th Edition

Garrison Bros. Texas Whiskey

[Bmac]

First time crossing threads, I hope that life as I know it does not stop and every molecule of my body explode at the speed of light.

Egon....you said crossing the threads was bad.....

[bad_scientist]

First time crossing threads, I hope that life as I know it does not stop and every molecule of my body explode at the speed of light.

Egon....you said crossing the threads was bad.....

This all could have been avoided if you'd answered "Yes" when asked if you're a god.

[HRay]

The VB 17 is tempting since it's a wheater..

[timd]

It's not just expensive. It's awful bourbon.

I'll second that - anybody wants a bottle of their earlier release, I may know somebody willing to part with some

Oh, and it's not easy to find, either - actually very limited, but in this case that's a GOOD thing! :hot: