What rye are you drinking or purchased 2025

[rzelinka]

45 minutes ago, Skinsfan1311 said:

The Small Batch rye, or Cask Strength or pretty much any of the picks if you can get your hands on one are good.    If you like the oak....then you'll probably like the Double Oaked.   They have some finished whiskey, but I've never tried them because I'm not a big fan.    I really, really need to get to the distillery, (it's only 15 minutes or so from the house), to try a few different ones..

Thank you. All of the ones you listed above are fairly easy to come by here.  It's interesting what is easy here is difficult elsewhere and vice versa

[Mattk]

9 hours ago, rzelinka said:

I’m going to pick up a bottle of sagamore this weekend. Not sure which one to buy. Any suggestions? The peerless double Oaked is also intriguing 

If you come across the 8 or 9 year bottles they are really something special. But pretty much everything they have is good.

[Anwalt]

Headed to the doctor’s office tomorrow. Turns out he loves rye. Which is not really sold much here in PR. So a care package helps the world go round.

 

 

[MSB]

11 hours ago, rzelinka said:

I’m going to pick up a bottle of sagamore this weekend. Not sure which one to buy. Any suggestions? The peerless double Oaked is also intriguing 

I really like the Cask .

 

I wanna try the 9yr but the price is holding me back, or is that cheap bastard in me that is keeping me from reaching for the wallet??

[MSB]

1 hour ago, Anwalt said:

Headed to the doctor’s office tomorrow. Turns out he loves rye. Which is not really sold much here in PR. So a care package helps the world go round.

 

 

I am not feeling well, may I get a care package?

[Kepler]

15 hours ago, rzelinka said:

I’m going to pick up a bottle of sagamore this weekend. Not sure which one to buy. Any suggestions? The peerless double Oaked is also intriguing 

My Sagamore vote, in order of my personal preference:

1.  9 Year

2.  8 Year (nearly as good as the 9, if you cannot find the 9)

3.  Store pick (most of these are 110 proof)  and I think the "Cask Strength" (non store picks) are probably just as good if you don't see a pick

4.  Sherry Finish

 

The Port finish is actually right up there at the top but it's a very limited annual release and almost impossible to find. 

Good luck and let us know what you end up with!